The truths and myths of a scalloped Fingerboard

What is a scalloped fingerboard? It is a fingerboard with it's fretboard, the space in between the frets filed away into a scoop like shape. The next question would be, why will I want that?

We have seen players such as Yngwie Malmsteen and Ritchie Blackmoore playing playing Fenders with Scalloped fingerboards and thanks to the wide popularity of these musicians, we came to a misguided conception that, if these players play with such a guitar, it must be easier to play with thus making us sound better as players right? Well, I hate to break your bubble but no, that is not the case. Often we buy our gear based on what our idol use thinking that it will make us closer to them in terms of playing (I am a victim of that) or configuring our gear closer to them. Sadly, nothing but hours of practice can do that.

I've read before that Scalloped fingerboards allow us to play faster, clearer tone and etc. Nope, breaking your bubble again, that isn't the case. I've scalloped a Squier just to try out how the scalloped fingerboard actually feels like. However, this is already done with the preconception of knowing that it is for and what it does. So, allow me to debunk the myths of a scalloped fingerboard.

Myth: It allows us to play faster.
Answer: This is above all the most misunderstood myth. It does not allow us to play faster. Think of it this way. Without the wood in between the frets, doesn't it makes it harder to slide around the fingerboard? However, we have the illusion of being able to play faster after getting used to the fingerboard because over time, we developed what I like to call light touch. The way we fret our notes have changed to accommodate the lack of support from the wood and any additional pressure will just make our notes go higher. Now, think of it this way, by fretting our notes lightly, it also means that we have less fatigue and takes way less effort to move around the neck right? So there you go. It's not that it's easier to play faster but it makes us adapted to fretting lightly.

Myth: There is a difference in Deep scallop and half scallop and other different depth of scallop.
Answer: No there isn't. When there isn't wood underneath your fingers, you feel nothing. Now does it matter when that nothing is half a cm or 1 cm? No. Think of it this way, u are floating in a 3m deep pool and 4m deep pool (Assuming you are not these heights), does it makes a difference in the space between your legs and the floor? No, you feel nothing.

Truth: It is harder to play with a scalloped fingerboard.
Answer: Yes, it is harder in a certain sense. However, once you get used to it, it really isn't that much harder. Remember the first time you picked up the guitar trying to learn how to alternate pick or economy pick, it's the same. Once you get it hardwired into your brain, it ain't that much harder. To me, the scalloped fingerboard just allows me to play with a light touch.

Myth: Super Jumbo frets feel like scallop finger boards since the frets are so high.
Answer: No it doesn't. Not at all. You are still touching the wood beneath your fingers. Having bigger taller frets doesn't makes it feel like a scalloped fingerboard. It only makes it feel closer to a scalloped fingerboard.

Truth: Scalloped fingerboards are easy to do string bending with.
Answer: Yes. In fact, a lot easier. The fact of not having any wood below your fingers means that there is no additional friction to stop you from using your full finger strength to push the strings up or down. Try not to break you strings.

Truth: Scalloped fingerboards are a lot easier to do vibrato with.
Answer: Yes. Same concept as bending. When there is no wood beneath your fingers, there is less friction.

Truth: Scalloping your fingerboard will change the tone of your instrument.
Answer: Yes it does. In fact, it makes it brighter. Think of it this way. No more direct contact to the wood. It's the frets, the wood supporting the frets and your fingers. Majority of the contact point is the fret and strings. (Think metal to metal)

Truth: Scalloping your fingerboard will make the guitar neck weaker
Answer: Yes and No. Yes to making the fingerboard weaker but no to making it weak to the point that even if your truss rod is at it's maximum potential, the neck will be warped. I've had my scalloped guitar being scalloped for close to 2 years now and it hasn't warp since the day I set it up.

For my readers who are interested in scalloped fingerboards, I hope I did answer your questions and doubts you have. Additionally, I hope that this debunk any myths of scalloped fingerboards. These is nothing magical about it. It's just something different.